[00:00:12]
I ASK, DID Y'ALL GET THE TRANSCRIPT TURNED ON ONE VOICEMAIL? UM, DO YOU WANT ME TO DO IT TO LEAVE IT TO YOU RIGHT NOW? CAN I EMAIL IT TO YOU? YOU CAN WRITE, YEAH.
WHAT DO YOU PREFER? BECAUSE I WAS WRITING IT, WRITING IT DOWN.
I'M GOING TO TAKE THE PAPER TO YOU.
RULE OF DISAPPROVE APPLICATION PERMISSION SHALL BE GUIDED BY THE CITY'S UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT DESIGN GUIDELINES AND STANDARDS THAT HAVE BEEN ADOPTED BY CITY.
HE OF A DECISION BY A ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICIAL FILED IN ACCORDANCE CITY'S UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT.
THOUGH MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC CAN WATCH THIS MEETING THROUGH LIVESTREAM FOLLOWING THE MEETING, A RECORDING WILL BE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY, IS BEING RECORDED IN SPANISH AND ENGLISH.
THOSE APPLICANTS OR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT REQUIRE INTERPRETIVE SERVICES INTERPRETER WILL TRANSLATE OVER THE PHONE AS NECESS.
APPLICANTS ARE ASKED TO KEEP PRESENTATIONS AS BRIEF POSSIBLE TO ALLOW TIME FOR DISCUSSION.
MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO ARE SPEAK OR OPPOSITION EACH HAVE A MAXIMUM OF TWO MINUTES FOR THEIR COMMENTS.
COMMISSIONERS WILL BE LIMITED TO FIVE MINUTES FOR QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS REGARDING EACH APPLICATION.
MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION, AS WELL AS MANY APPLICANTS ARE PARTICIPATING VIRTUALLY TODAY.
WE ASK THAT THOSE WHO ARE ATTENDING EITHER IN VIRTUALLY, HE CLEARLY INTO A MICROPHONE SO EVERYONE CAN HEAR COMMENTS IN ORDER TO PROTECT PUBLIC SAFETY AND HEALTH MASKS ARE STRONGLY ENCOURAGED FOR ANYONE ATTENDING.
APPROVAL BY THE COMMISSION DOES NOT TAKE THE PLACE OF ANY TYPE OF PERMIT.
PERMITS MUST BE OBTAINED FOR ALL WORK.
CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS FOR WORK APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION MAIL TO YOU WITH NO WORK OF ANY TYPE IS TO BE STARTED WITHOUT OBTAINING THE APPROPRIATE CITY PERMITS AFTER A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS HAS BEEN ISSUED BY THE OFFICE OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION.
AT THIS TIME, I'LL ASK O STAFF TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL INSTRUCTIONS FOR TODAY'S MEETING.
UM, YES, BEFORE WE DO GET STARTED, UM, CHAIRMAN, SECOND MOTION.
GROUP RUN THIS, THAT, SIR? AYE.
UM, AND THEN WE ALSO HAVE A TIME THAT ITEM WILL NOT BE HEARD.
[00:05:01]
WELL WATCHING, UH, FOR THIS ITEM CUT OFF IS NOT FOUR 30, UM, WHICHEVER IS LATER IS THAT ITEM.UM, SO NOW AT THIS TIME WE'LL GO STARTING OFF VOICEMAILS FOR ITEM NUMBER 3, 5 0 4 AUSTIN.
HELLO, MY NAME IS VALERIE
I'M CALLING TODAY ON BEHALF OF CASE NUMBER 2022 DASH SEVEN EIGHT, LOCATED AT 5 0 4 AUSTIN STREET, THE CITIZENS AND AND NEIGHBORS OF DIGNITY HILL SUPPORT O H P STIPULATIONS.
BUT DUE TO THE FACT THAT THIS PARTICULAR APPLICANT HAS A LONG HISTORY OF NOT FOLLOWING O H P GUIDELINES, ESPECIALLY STIPULATIONS PROVIDED AFTER RECEIVING APPROVAL ON PROPOSED PLANS, WE ARE REQUESTING THAT O H P STAFF DILIGENTLY INSPECT ALL APPROVED WORK TO ENSURE THIS APPLICANT ADHERES TO STIPULATIONS FROM THIS MEETING AND PREVIOUS MEETING.
MY NAME IS KATHY VIC, 1 0 7 KING WILLIAMS STREET, SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS 7 8 2 0 4.
THIS IS IN REGARDS TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER 3 5 0 4 AUSTIN STREET.
THE CONSERVATION SOCIETY OF SAN ANTONIO REMAINS CONCERNED ABOUT THE PROPOSED THIRD STORY EDITION.
PREVIOUS ITERATIONS OF THE DESIGN WERE STEPPED BACK.
SO NOT TO OVERWHELM THE ORIGINAL ONE STORY STRUCTURE.
WHILE THE PROPOSED DESIGN ELIMINATES SOLID MASSES AT THE REAR OF THE ADDITION, THE DARK CANOPY STRUCTURE VISUALLY CREATES A SCALE THAT IS NO LONGER COMPATIBLE WITH THE HISTORIC PARTS OF THE STRUCTURE.
THAT WAS ONCE THE LA FAMA BAKERY.
THIS IS FOR CASE NUMBER, AGENDA ITEM NUMBER EIGHT.
THE ADDRESS 2 1 2 7 WEST SUMMIT AVENUE.
MY NAME IS BIANCA MALTO AND I'M THE CHAIR OF THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMITTEE FOR THE MONTICELLO PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
AND I OFFER COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF DREA GARZA AND THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS FOR THE MONTICELLO PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION.
OUR ADDRESS IS PO BOX 1 0 0 3 1 5 7 8 2 0 1.
WE APPRECIATE HOMEOWNERS WHO INVEST IN THEIR PROPERTIES SPECIFICALLY ARE IN THEIR HISTORIC HOMES.
UH, WE DO CONCUR WITH STAFF RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL, UH, FOR THIS PARTICULAR CASE.
UH, FOR THE ENCLOSURE OF THE COURT SCREEN, WE DO NOTE THAT WORK BEGAN WITHOUT A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS.
THERE WERE OTHER IMAGES, THE FORMER COUNTRY,
[00:10:01]
RIO, HOWEVER WE[00:15:22]
GIBB FISH.SABINA QUE CARPENTER? NO, JUST C CARPENTER.
[00:20:52]
I CAN HEAR YOU.UH, MCC NINE MCLURE AND SAY THOSE SAYS NO,
[00:25:38]
THE CONSISTENT.CERVANTES C, FE C BECAUSE THOSE PLANTERS
[00:30:54]
A GOOD UNDERSTANDING WHERE IT SHOULD.SO, UM, CAN WE, UM, BUT, UM, OPEN TO YOUR, UH, SUGGESTIONS.
I THINK I'M COMMISSIONER FISHER IS CORRECTLY.
[00:35:04]
YOU GO.[00:41:44]
PLEASE.SO THEY'RE, THEY'RE BEING REMOVED TO SPEAK TO WHEN I STARTED.
[00:46:32]
CARPENTER[00:54:22]
YOU RECOMMEND GIBBS.[00:55:45]
RESPECT TO METALL.SHE THE ION THE FORMER CHARACTERISTICS.
[01:03:13]
T[01:05:32]
DRAFT CRAFTMAN OR S S LAS VEGAS ION THE CRAFTMAN[01:10:24]
CRAFT.[01:19:04]
I, SORRY, MR.[01:21:36]
PARTICIP.[01:25:15]
CONSTRUCTION.[01:36:55]
CEREMONIAL[01:37:01]
WE'RE NOT PERSON.[01:40:19]
NO.COMMISSIONER GIBBS C FISH OR NO? NO.
REPEAT THE I C SABINO C I'LL ASK IT.
[01:45:02]
CERVANTES? NO.[01:51:37]
HISTORICAL.UM, FERNANDO, ARE YOU, UM, SENIOR? CHRIS? FERNANDO.
UH, DIDN'T KNOW IT WAS GONNA BE A OKAY, CHRIS, NO.
[01:58:29]
C FISH.C, S, C, VELAZQUEZ, CARPENTER, C GROUP C, MORE CASES BEFORE WE GET TO THE I THE SUPPOSED BE FOUR 30.
BUT THERE WAS NO DEFINITE TIME WHEN WE HAD TO ORDER
[02:00:51]
MATERIAL INFRACTION, NO ION REVISION.UM, EVERYTHING THAT'S BEEN, UH, WORKED ON HAS ALL BEEN INSIDE THE HOUSE COUPLE WEEKS AGO.
AND, UM, I DON'T KNOW IF IT WAS A MISUNDERSTANDING QUESTION.
UM, AND SHE DID SAY THAT I CAN DO ANYTHING INSIDE THE HOUSE AND JUST SAT OUTSIDE.
SO, UM, NOT SURE IF I, IF THAT'S YEAH.
AND I BELIEVE THAT, UH, WE ARE COMPLYING WITH,
[02:05:38]
THERE'S A SHED THAT IV COMMISSION.BUT IS RE CAN YOU AND WHAT IS CURRENTLY KILLED GRANDE THE REVISION?
[02:10:06]
RECOMMENDED.SO I CAN BETTER UNDERSTAND OR YOU GUYS WANNA GIS? C FISH.
[02:15:21]
IN EVERGREEN.IF YOU COULD GO TO THE ORIGINAL PREVIOUSLY.
[02:24:04]
C FISH.C, S C QUE MA CARPENTER C GROUP CERVANTES.
C C PROJECT TO THE ROCKY BRIDGE.
[02:27:04]
NO, GO FIRST.NO, WHAT THEY'RE PROPOSING BEFORE WE SPEAK, PLEASE, THEY'RE GONNA LIE.
OKAY, LET'S HAVE A, A SHORT PRESENTATION BY GOOD AFTERNOON, MR. MY NAME IS DERIDGE.
[02:30:45]
SO HERE'S THE PROJECT AREA, UH, LIMITS YOU HAVE, UM, IS HILDER IS THE SHOW YOU LATER BROKEN OUT INTO TWO, UH, UH, TWO PAGES, BUT IT INCLUDES, SO HERE'S THE LITTLE GRAIN, RIGHT? THAT'S ANTONIO AND I HAVE SEVERAL PHOTOS.[02:37:00]
IMPLEMENTING SIMILARITIES.[02:41:26]
HISTORICAL.[02:45:29]
RESTROOM DEMOLITION.SO TREES HELP PREVENT FLOODING.
THEY MINIMIZE OR THEY HELP MINIMIZE SOIL EROSION.
WE NEED PROBLEM IS THEY AUDIO.
BRACKRIDGE PARK IS IN A FLOOD ZONE.
IT'S UH, UH, FEMA HAS A PROGRAM AND WE, SAN ANTONIO HAS A FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT OFFICE WHO HAVE NOT RECEIVED A PERMIT.
YOU PERMIT TAKE BECAUSE THEY'RE IN, THEY HAVE NOT RECEIVED SUCH PERMIT OR REQUEST DOCUMENT.
INDIAN VILLAGE SAN ANTONIO NOT EVEN REACHED OUT TO MY IN SAN ANTONIO.
[02:50:05]
ANTONIO INCARNATE ISEN.[02:55:58]
ARMSTRONG.[03:00:26]
RICHARD REED.YES, I CAN, THERE'S I IS DIFFERENT.
[03:05:04]
WHEN I STARTED ROSE HILL, JUST SAN ANTONIO NAME ROSE.[03:11:34]
UM, I'M HISTORIC DISTRICT AND THIS CASE THE TRAIN, CARLOS OX LAS IS THE RANDOLPH PERSON.[03:15:06]
AND TAKE A SPECIFIC TO PULL MY BODY WHILE THROUGHOUT THE, I SPECIFICALLY ON THE REMOVED I, NOT THAT THOSE TREES LEFT TREES HAVE SPENT YEARS UPON YEARS STACKING CELLULAR TISSUE AND GROWTH BASED OFF OF OUR WASTE, BASED OFF OF OUR CARBON DIOXIDE.AND THEY HAVE STOOD AND WITHSTOOD THE TEST OF TIME, HISTORIC FLOOD, REMOVING TREES OF THAT SIDE THAT HAVE EXPERIE SYSTEMS THAT HOLD ON THAT MUCH SOIL.
AND HAVING A PLAN WHERE YOU DECIDE TO PLANT, SORRY, STANDARD WE PLAN ON REPLACING.
THAT WILL BE, THAT IS BIGGEST CONCERN I HAVE PERSONALLY RECREATION ELLE HEATHER.
[03:20:56]
ASTORIA.VER DE SAN ANTONIO, LOCAL RIVER NATIVE SPECIES AND GRASSES.
PLANTS EDIBLE IN I GIVEN ALTERNATIVE I ANTONIO.
AND POSSIBLE THERE ARE ENGINEERS THAT CAN FIX THE SITUATION WITHOUT HAVING REMOVE IT'S POSSIBLE, POSSIBLE IT'S POSSIBLE.
[03:25:42]
THANK YOU.MAL HAD RACCOONS IN MY END OF MY FRONT YARD.
SO IF YOU DON'T WANT WILDLIFE IN, YOU DON'T LIVE NEXT TO THEM.
SO I HAD MY, MY QUESTIONS WERE RESTRICTIONS.
HAVE THE HISTORIC NATIONAL REGISTRAR, UM, WHAT, WHAT PROBLEM? UM, SURE.
UH, MOTOR ALLEN TELLING PEOPLE NOT, UH, WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO MOVE WALLS FORWARD OR BACKWARD OR JUST, OR OTHERWISE DISTANCE THE WALLS FROM ANY OF THE JURISDICTION PLACED UPON US.
AGAIN, IF WE DON'T HAVE THE HISTORICAL DESIGNATION, WHERE ARE THE RESTRICTIONS? I DON'T.
UH, YEAH, THE OTHER PROJECT AREAS WILL PUT UP AGAIN BECAUSE AREA IS HORRIBLE.
I WAS THERE ON A TOUR ON SOME, I DON'T REMEMBER IT.
MAYBE THEY JUST TOOK REALLY GOOD SHOTS TO MAKE THEIR, BUT UM, HOW ARE THOSE TREES ALLOWED TO GROW FOR SO LONG? UH, TO, TO CRUMBLE THOSE STRUCTURES? THAT'S ONE THING I WANNA KNOW.
AND IT ALSO MAKES ME FEARFUL FOR THE 400 NEW, UM, IF THAT'S THE STATE OF THE PARK, UH, UP TO THIS POINT, WHAT HAPPENED TO THEM? ANOTHER THING I'D LIKE TO KNOW ABOUT, UH, UM, ANYBODY DONE ANY ECAC STUDIES? WATER, HOW MUCH IS THAT GONNA COST? THAT'S ALREADY GIVING THE CITY BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
WHAT'S THE BALANCE? UM, AGAIN, NOT ALL THE TREES ARE GONNA GO INTO THE PARK THAT ON THE TOUR FIT ALL OF THOSE TREES.
SO WHERE ARE THEY GONNA GO? ARE THEY GONNA BE BUILT? ARE THE TREES PUT IN ARCHEOLOGICAL, HAVE ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES IN IT THAT'S GONNA REQUIRE START DIGGING AN ARCHEOLOGICAL.
NONE OF THIS WAS DISCUSSED IN THE 2017, UH, BOND PROJECT.
SO WAS THERE AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STUDY FLOOD PLAIN TREE.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE ROOTS BROUGHT IN THE GROUND.
THEY'RE NOT GONNA PROVIDE ANY SERVICE.
SO ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STUDY, BECAUSE FLOODINGS GONNA HAPPEN HAPPENED BECAUSE YOU REPLACED THE TREES.
YOU'RE NOT GONNA GET ANY SERVICE OUT OF THOSE TREES FOR 400 TREES.
SOUNDS NICE, BUT WILL THEY ALL MAKE IT? HOW MUCH WATER ARE WE GONNA SPEND? HOW MUCH MONEY ARE YOU GONNA SPEND ON WATER AND CARE? DOES IT, DOES IT BALANCE OUT NET NEGATIVE OR A NET POSITIVE FOR THE PROJECT? I'D LIKE TO KNOW THOSE.
BUT AGAIN, DON'T EVEN HAVE THE PERMIT.
HOW ARE THEY GOING AROUND SAYING THAT WE HAVE THESE RESTRICTIONS.
WE MUST DO THIS MUST LEAVE, THESE MUST REMOVE THESE, HAVE THE DESIGNATION LIKE THEM TO GO BACK.
[03:30:02]
I'M ACTUALLY GONNA HEAR OF LIFE.I EMPATHIZE WITH THE, I WANNA THANK THE GET RID OF THESE.
[03:35:01]
SEELEFT SIDE OF THE TREES HAVE COEX ENTIRE, EVERY SINGLE.
BUT I WOULD URGE YOU RIGHT, SO, UM,
I HAVE PEOPLE AS A SO COUNSEL HAVE TO REMINDER CYCLE OF LIFE.
IT'S AN AGREEMENT, A RELATIVE.
[03:40:11]
HIKED BRACKENRIDGE PARK, CHOP MY CHILDREN UP.SOME LIGHT BIRDS ARE PART OF OUR NATURAL, I COUNTED FOR THAT IS NOT GONNA STOP.
AND THEY WILL MOST LIKELY NOT GONNA HAVE, HAVE TO GO THOSE TREES.
IT'S NOT GONNA THOSE THERE ARE VERY FEW NATURAL AREAS FOR, OKAY, WE HAVE YOUR OH, OKAY.
RACHEL, GARLIC, BU BURNS AND ANTONIO.
FORMER, I'M CALLING NUMBER 23.
I URGE YOU TO IS REMOVING FAR TOO MANY LARGE HISTORIC TREES.
AND UH, I'M SURE THAT WITH SMALLER EQUIPMENT AND PERHAPS MORE LABOR INTENSIVE WORK, THE RESTORATION COULD BE DONE WITHOUT MITIGATION TO PREVENT ROOTS INTRUSION INTO SOME OF THE STONE WORK COULD BE DONE TO PRESERVE MANY OF THESE TREES ALONG THE PROXIMITY.
UM, MORE EFFORT NEEDS TO BE MADE.
[03:45:11]
NO, THE BRACKENRIDGE PARK, NO BRACKENRIDGE GRASSES WHEN I STARTED IS ONLY REGARDING, AGAIN, FROM ALL THE TREES BEING WELL, TREES BEING CUT FROM GAREN BRIDGE PARK, BRACKENRIDGE, THIS IS A VERY HISTORIC PARK FOR OUR CITY.IT LOOKS LIKE IT HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED SINCE 1899.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND SAN REMOVE RESILIENCE EXIST.
BRACKENRIDGE IS ANONYMOUS, IS SAN ANTONIO BRACKENRIDGE, NC
[03:50:33]
LOS LAS THE RIVER ROAD DO IS FORCE THEM TO DO THAT AND THEN THEY WILL BECOME A PROBLEM FOR THOSE PEOPLE.WE HAVE TO WORK WITH NATURE, NATURE AND TREES FOR JUST AS MUCH DOWN HAPPENED BEHIND.
UH, BRACKENRIDGE, UH, PARK TREES.
YOU GUYS DON'T MIND OBVIOUSLY.
UM, OBVIOUSLY CARE, YOU KNOW, IT'S BEAUTIFUL TO WALK DOWN THERE AND SEE HIM.
THANK HOWEVER I CONCEPT OF THE RIGHTS OF NATURE.
WE DEFENDED OUR LOCAL TREE ORDINANCE ONLY TO SEE THOUSANDS OF TREES.
MILITARY, YOUR PERSONAL RE I ZERO EIGHT STREET
[03:55:11]
IN ST.MARY'S, BRACKENRIDGE PARK, ANTONIO AVENUE IN BRACKENRIDGE ENVIRONMENT.
NICE PARK THE RIVER, WHICH IS NICE AND NICE.
ALSO WEAR REGULAR RIVER PARK TO SEE ALL THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF WILDLIFE AND ALL THIS, ALL THE BIRDS, THE DUCK, THE
[04:00:04]
RICHARD GONZALEZ GONZALEZ, SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS.NO, IT ALSO THE PARKING ISSUES.
AND OLA RE I'M CALLING, UM, ABOUT THE A C R C MEETING.
AND I WANT TO CALL ABOUT THE, THE, UH, THREE MARKED FOR TALKING DOWN IN BRA.
AND THIS IS WHAT I HAVE TO SAY.
THE HERITAGE TREES MARK FOR REMOVAL ARE WHERE THE S FRUIT, THE S ARE AN ATTRACTION FOR MANY OF US WHO LIVE HERE AS WELL AS CHURCH.
DURING THE FEW MONTHS THEY HERE, YOU KNOW, MAGICAL THE ARGUMENT IS ABOUT THE WATER QUALITY WHILE THEY ROUTE.
ACCORDING TO THE SAN ANTONIO RIVER AUTHORITY, BACTERIAL SOLUTIONS IS THE LARGEST PROBLEM WITH THE SAN ANTONIO RIVER.
THE MAIN SOURCE IS IN THE PARKING LOT.
THAT AREA OF PAVEMENT AND ASPHALT IS WHERE BACTERIA COLLECTS REMOVING TREES DRAMATICALLY ADD TO THIS PROBLEM.
AND ONCE THESE TREES ARE GONE, I WILL NOT BE AROUND FOR THE 200 YEARS FOR ANOTHER ONE TO GROW BACK.
WHEN YOU, AGAIN, MY NAME IS TERRY.
I ABOUT REMOVING HARRIS STREET HAND SAN ANTONIO A WEEK AND
[04:05:08]
THE INVESTIGATION.HI, MY NAME IS ISMA HARRIS AND I AM CALLING REGARDING THE BRACKENRIDGE TREE REMOVAL.
I'M CALLING BECAUSE I BELIEVE THERE SHOULD BE MORE TIME TAKEN, UM, TO CONSIDER REMOVING THESE TREES.
A LOT OF THE COMMUNITY MEMBERS WERE NOT AWARE THAT THESE HERITAGE TREES WERE GOING TO BE REMOVED.
THAT WHOLE AREA ALONG THE SAN ANTONIO RIVER IS ALSO SACRED TO SOME OF THE INDIGENOUS PEOPLE THAT WERE THERE.
IF BRECKENRIDGE IS, YOU KNOW, SO CONCERNED WITH RESERVING HISTORY AND THEY SHOULD ALSO BE CONCERNED ABOUT NOTATING SACRED FIGHTS, THOSE TREES ARE ALSO PART OF HISTORY AND THEY SHOULD BE PRESERVED.
I'M SURE THAT YOU GUYS ARE SMART ENOUGH TO COME UP WITH OTHER WAYS TO REPAIR WHAT YOU NEED TO REPAIR WITHOUT INFRINGING UPON NATURE OF THE WILDLIFE THAT SURROUNDS THAT AREA.
HELLO, MY NAME IS CRYSTAL MARTIN.
UM, I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT OF FAIR COUNTY, THE CITY OF SAN ANTONIO FOR THE PAST 41 YEARS.
UM, I'M ACTUALLY REACHING OUT REGARDING THE RECENT, UH, TALK.
UH, OR I BELIEVE I READ THAT THERE WAS A NOTICE OF THE HEARING FOR THE HISTORIC AND DESIGN FOR SAN ANTONIO REGARDING SOME TREES, UH, THAT ARE HUGE.
THEY OLDER TREES AT BRACKENRIDGE PARK.
UH, SO MY FAMILY AND I FOR YEARS, UM, YOU KNOW, RIGHT YEARS TO COME IN THE FUTURE.
ALSO, NOW THAT I ALSO HAVE GRANDCHILDREN, UH, WE'VE ALWAYS, YOU KNOW, LOOKED AT BRACKENRIDGE PARK AS THE PEOPLE OF THE CITY.
UM, YOU KNOW, THIS, UH, CITY PARK THAT EVERYBODY AND ANYBODY'S WELCOME TO FREE OF CHARGE IN REGARDS TO CUTTING THE TREES.
I'M NOT SURE IF THERE'S DEVELOPMENTS, TALK OF DEVELOPMENTS.
WHAT'S THE REASONING BEHIND IT? HOWEVER, IT JUST HAS SENTIMENTAL VALUE.
IS THE PEACE A TREASURE APART PART OF THE PARK? HUGE PART OF THE PARK.
IT PROVIDES THE HOME, IT PROVIDES THE ANIMALS AND WILDLIFE.
I'M NOT PROPERLY EDUCATED OR TRAINED IN, YOU KNOW, DEVELOPMENT AND WILDLIFE.
HOWEVER, UH, I PERSONALLY DO NOT AGREE WITH CUTTING DOWN THE TREES.
I MEAN, IF THERE'S DEVELOPMENTAL ISSUES IN REGARDS TO A BLOCKING GAS PIPES, ELECTRICITY PIPE, WATER PIPES, I CAN SEE THE NEED.
IT WORKED FOR THE CITY, IT WORKED FOR ME.
I'M SURE WORKED FOR ALL OTHERS THAT IF THERE WAS SUCH AN ISSUE OR A PROBLEM OR PEOPLE WANTED THEM CUT, THEY PROBABLY WOULD'VE STARTED A POSITION IN THE OTHER DIRECTION.
UH, DEFINITELY THINK THAT IT NEEDS TO BE LEFT ALONE.
THE CHANGES THAT YOU GUYS ARE MAKING.
SOME OF RE IS IN SOLO IN LAURA MORALES WITH AVENUE RIDGE
[04:10:18]
RECONSTRUCTION.I APPRECIATE IT BECAUSE I'LL HAVE TO BE PREVENTABLE.
VE UM, OR, UM, YEAH, I, I JUST DON'T, I, UH, IT IT THINGS LIKE A WASTE OF A IS UNNECESSARY.
THE, MY NAME IS REON WITH SENIOR OF LUCKY PERSONA.
HI, MY NAME IS OLA ANTONIO, TEXAS.
[04:15:02]
PLAN DRIVE SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS.TO SANCHEZ, HE SAYS SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS.
ROY WOULD KNOW THOSE ARE MORE RIDGE PARK
[04:20:25]
RESTRICTION.THE ARE POLICE CANNOT SEE IDENTIFI AND PRESERVED IN THE CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENT PRESERVED SEVENTH TO BE ON THE PLAN ON ONE PAGE THERE TO BE PRESERVED AND ANOTHER CASE THERE BE TO BE REMOVED.
SHER AVENUE, LOS RIDGE, LOS LAS NATURE.
THEY BELONG THERE AND INTERFERENCE THE COUNTY.
[04:25:14]
MUNICIPALITY.ANTONIO TO THE ME WITH RESPECT TO DISCIPLIN LAB PROTECTION IN ST.
MARY'S, 30 ANTONIO IN RECIA, CIA, RIO SAN ANTONIO
[04:30:24]
DIRECTION IS CINCO AVENUE, SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS LA DIRECTION DE WHEN I IS PROBABLY DELAWARE STREET IN SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS PLAN IS THE[04:35:08]
TO THAT HISTORY.BUT I CAN'T, DON'T HAVE I WHICH TREES ARE PLANTED BECAUSE TREES WILL BE CUT WITHOUT THAT.
AT LEAST HUNDRED TREES ARE GONNA REPLACE THEM.
EVEN WITH THAT BE ANNOUNCED, THE NEW ONES ARE GONNA TAKE YEARS TO GROW THAT.
IN OTHER WORDS, I DON'T AGREE.
SO THAT'S ALL OF OUR, I DO WANNA THANK SENIOR, SENIOR MORENO.
UM, WE'RE GONNA, UM, ASK JESSICA, SHE
[04:43:31]
SO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION EARLIER ABOUT OVER OUR PROJECT BECAUSE OF, UH, THE, THE WATERWAY, THE SAN ANTONIO RIVER THEIA, UM, THE, UH, UH, THE, UH, RACEWAY[04:45:01]
AS WELL.UM, AND SO, YOU KNOW, WE'VE BEEN TALKING WITH THE T H C FOR APPROXIMATELY 18 MONTHS, HAVING MULTIPLE MEETINGS WITH HIM AND DISCUSSING WHAT PERMITTING PROCESS RESPONSIBLY.
WE HAVE BEEN DISCUSSING THE PROJECT WITH THE FOUR ENGINEER FOR THE LAST FEW MONTHS.
UM, WE, WE HAVEN'T, UH, GONE DOWN THE PATH OF WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF WE REMOVED THE WALLS OR MOVE WALLS IN, BUT WE UNDERSTAND THE IMPLICATIONS OF DOING THAT WITH FOUR YEARS, UH, SINCE WE'RE IN THE FLOOD CLAIM.
UM, THAT WOULD CHANGE THE WHOLE MAKEUP OF THE HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD CLAIM.
UM, THAT WOULD, UH, CHOKE DOWN THAT AREA.
UH, IT WOULD ADD, UH, FILL INTO THE A HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD CLAIM.
YOU'RE BASICALLY ADDING FILL BEHIND THEM.
UM, AND THAT WOULD HAVE, UH, IMPACTS DOWN ES TREES ALONG THE RIVER.
[04:50:13]
IN THOSE IS STANDS IN PARK.[04:58:48]
CONSTRUCTION, SUPERFICIAL, THE RIVER, RIVER[05:00:07]
AFFECT.[05:05:52]
MISSION.SOUTH AMERICA FOR MY, FOR MY, I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT, UM,
[05:10:06]
SEVERAL DIFFERENT EXPERTS.K T N A, WE HAVE ENGINEERS, WE HAVE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, UH, WE HAVE ARCHITECTS, WE HAVE HISTORICAL ARCHITECTS.
UM, WE HAVE CIVIL ENGINEER, STRUCTURAL ENGINEER, ENGINEERS, LU NOISE THROUGH A CAN.
THE TIMING, REMOVING THE TREES IS A LITTLE SOMETHING DIFFERENT.
UM, SO OUR SCHEDULE RIGHT NOW, THE WHOLE PROJECT THAT YOU'VE SEEN, UH, WE DECIDED TO BREAK UP INTO TWO PHASES.
THE FIRST PHASE BEING LANGUAGE, UM, AND REALLY BECAUSE OF THE URGENCY OF DEALING WITH THOSE FAILING STRUCTURES.
UM, WE DON'T HAVE, UM, CAN'T REALLY SPEAK TO THE SCHEDULE, THE REST OF THE PROJECT PART OF THIS LIKE QUESTION CONSTRUCTION.
JUST RECENTLY, LAST YEAR, SOME OF IT PROBABLY FIVE YEARS AGO, SOME OF IT PROBABLY 10 YEARS AGO, AND FALLEN LAST AS NATURALIZATION.
[05:15:15]
RECONSTRUCTION, THE REPLANT, WE'LL HAVE, WE'LL COME TO THIS COMMISSION WITH DETAILED PLANS IN APRIL OR MAY SAY, UH, REQUEST FOR, SO THE ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS FOR REMOVAL OF THE TREES THAT ARE SPECIFIC TO THE RIVERBANK.SO THE, THE OVERALL PLAN FOR THIS AREA IS LARGER.
IT'S A LARGER NUMBER OF TREES, BUT THOSE NOT REQUIRE.
SO MY QUESTION MS. MR. CHAIR? YES SIR.
UM, VERY DIFFICULT, VERY DIFFICULT POSITION TO BE IN TIMES WHEN, UM, I WANT THANK, I'VE GOTTA TELL YOU, PARDON ME.
[05:21:02]
LATINO AND, AND ALL MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY AS WELL.THERE, THERE'S A LOT OF VERY IMPORTANT THINGS I'S I UNDERSTAND THAT IT'S NOT WHAT YOU WANT TO HEAR.
THERE'S A SITUATION WHERE THERE'S A BUILDING AND, AND THERE'S A, A ROAD THAT I ASKED HIM TO, YOU KNOW, WHAT'S THE POSSIBILITY OF CREATING A BRIDGE BECAUSE OF THE CRUISING THAT GOES ON, RIGHT? I THINK SOMEONE SPOKE ABOUT THAT AND I BELIEVE THAT THAT COULD BE DONE.
BUT IF YOU LOOK TO THE WEST SIDE OF THAT ROAD, THERE'S A BUILDING WITH A STONE STUCK IN IT.
AND THESE GENTLEMEN BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION THAT THAT STONE IS A KEYSTONE TO AN ARCH THAT'S UNDERGROUND THE ARCH IT WAS COVERED.
SEE, AND THEY WOULD DO THINGS LIKE THAT WHEN THEY ABANDONED THESE LOCATIONS, RIGHT? SO THERE'S NO POSSIBLE WAY OF GETTING TO THOSE ARCHES WITHOUT UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE'S A TREE COVERING, WHICH IS NOT ST.
[05:25:19]
IN OPINION MEXICAN CULTURAL.THE IS S UNIVERSITY IN ATE A WALKING PEDESTRIAN PATH AND CONNECT TO OUR AREA, WHICH THEN CONNECT TO THE 1776.
SO ALL THESE THINGS GO TOGETHER.
I MEAN, UM, IT A FACTOR WE NEED TO INCLUDE ALL NO AS INTERPRET.
[05:31:46]
NO, I UNDERSTAND YOU'D LIKE TO SEE LOS UH, LASS.NO, I, NO I THAT NOTHING UNKNOWN THERE.
LA CLEARLY ARE SOME THINGS THAT MUST BE REMOVED THAT IS DAMAGING THE COMMISSIONER.
I KNOW THIS IS JUST WISHING HERITAGE TREES A COUPLE OF TO BE SAVED BY MOVING THE, AND I KNOW THAT THAT SOUNDS HORRIBLE TO PRESERVATIONISTS,
[05:35:01]
BUT APPRECIATE EVERYBODY'S NOT NECESS COMMISSIONER GIBBS.I WANT BE BECAUSE, UM, UM, FELLOW, UM, MS. S DOING SOME OTHER THINGS THAT WE CAN HELP MAKE THE SITUATION.
HE MUST BE OPTION THE NAME MO THE YEAR IN PARTICULAR AREA CAMP.
THE IMPACT YES TO LOW KEEPING SOME MO I I SAID EARLIER, UH, PLAN THE PROCESS WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND WITH APPROVED.
SO, YOU KNOW, THAT TYPE OF MITIGATION HAS TO BE DONE BY US.
IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE'RE GONNA, IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE'RE GONNA FORGET ABOUT.
[05:40:01]
PER THE U C CODE.WE'RE GOING TO FOLLOW THAT WITH OUR PROJECT.
SO, YOU KNOW, I, I HEAR THESE, THESE DIFFERENT ITERATIONS NOISE THAN SO MANY MORE TREES THAN WE COULD PROPOSED.
DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? HONOR, I ASK I CRITERIA POSSIBLY THAT RA RESPECT
[05:48:57]
THE CONTROLLER STOR RIVERTON RIDGE PARK, RIGHT? SO THEN NORTH OF THAT, IT'S NATURAL SOUTH OF THAT[05:50:01]
IT'S NATURAL UNTIL GETS TO THE RIVER WATER.WE DO HAVE THOSE AREAS AND THERE ARE SPEC, THERE ARE GRAVE SAMPLES OF WHERE THE TREES ARE AND WHERE THEY'RE, AND WHERE THEY'RE HELPING IN DEALING WITH THAT ISSUE.
UM, IN ORDER TO KEEP THAT BANKS, THOSE BANKS AND KEEP, KEEP THOSE THINGS WORKING.
THIS IS, WE'RE DOING DAMAGE TO THINGS, UM, THAT WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO.
ESPECIALLY THESE WALLS ARE IN THE REGISTRY.
THEY ARE CONTRIBUTING TEACHERS.
SO, UM, UH, I WOULD LIKE, IF YOU HAVE TO CLARIFY, UM, WHAT, UH, ACTION WE WOULD, UM, REQUEST AN ACTION.
I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SAY, UH, IN RESPONSE TO, UM, THE COMMISSIONER'S REQUEST FOR A SEPARATE MEETING, UM, I, THAT WE WOULD'VE ANYTHING NEW.
SO AGAIN, BY SECTION 35 6 8, UM, THIS INCLUDES THE THREE HERITAGES, TWO HERITAGE, ONE HERITAGE FALLS, AND ONE
[05:55:08]
IN WITH RACHEL IS A PHOTOGRAPHER.[06:00:31]
OCCUR AFTER CITY FOREST, THE 60 DAYS.YES, IT'S MARCH FOR 60 DAYS MOTION.
I CONVERSATION ASSISTANT TO THE LAW.
UM, I, I I WANNA MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE WHO DID THAT?
[06:07:05]
YES, THIS IS RESPONS FOR, IT'S IMPORTANT THE BELIEVE THAT YOU CAN, UH, SHOW US THAT AND PULL THAT RABBIT OUT A HAT.AND, AND IF YOU DO, I WOULD ASK COMMISSIONER TO RESCIND HIS MOTION.
ALLOW US TO MAKE A MOTION FOR A SPECIAL MEETING.
ANTONIO, I WOULD, THE SPECIAL MEETING HAS TO FOLLOW THE SAME FORMAT, BUT THAT'S, THERE'S STILL A MOTION ON THE TAPE.
COMMISSIONER, MR. CHAIRMAN, THE, THE 60 DAYS WAS A REACTION FROM REACTION, SAME EXERCISE
[06:10:14]
THAT THEY COULD RESPOND TO THE CONCERNS THAT THEY'VE HEARD HERE TODAY, UH, BY THE NEXT REGULAR HT R C HEARING.WHEN YOU SAY RESPOND TO SOME OF THE CONCERNS, WHICH CONCERNS SPECIFIC TO FROM THE, FROM THE COMMISSION, IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE YOU'RE GOING TO, TO RECEIVE SUPPORT FOR MOTION OF APPROVAL.
AND YOU'VE HEARD CONCERNS FROM THOSE CERTIFICATIONS? WELL, UH, I'LL SAY THAT.
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS, THE ACTION FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS FOR YOU IS FOR REMOVAL.
WE ARE NOT PREPARED TO BRING FORTH THE PLANS FOR, UM, CONSTRUCTION WORK AT THE LAMBERT BEACH AREA.
SO FOR YOU'RE NOT PREPARED TO BRING FORWARD PLANS FOR THE RESTORATION RECONSTRUCTION AND STABILIZATION OF THE WALLS TO THE LEVEL, TO THE LEVEL THAT WE WOULD TYPICALLY BRING THEM TO THE H D R C? NO, NOT IN A WEEK.
UM, HAVE A MOTION MR. CHAIR? YES, SIR.
MR. CHAIR, JUST, JUST TO, JUST TO PUT SOME FLEXIBILITY INTO THE SYSTEM.
I'LL, I'LL REDUCE THE 60 DAYS TO 30 DAYS, WHICH WILL BE A MONTH.
AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC COULD EXPECT THAT, UH, THERE'S SOME REASONABLE AMOUNT OF TIME TO BECOME MORE INFORMED ABOUT THE SITUATION.
AND IF IT TAKES LONGER THAN THAT, THE, AND REGARDING TO MY SECOND AND AMENDING MY SECOND, IF, UM, WE'RE NOT LOOKING AT NEW INFORMATION, THEN I CANNOT ENDORSE THE SECOND I WOULD LIKE TO RETRACT.
I'D LIKE TO SPEAK TO MR. FISHER'S CONCERN TIMELINE.
THE FUTURE IS IN LAMB BEACH CONDITIONING SIMILARITIES.
SENIOR PRESIDENT FOR PER MOTION.
[06:15:06]
MR. CHAIR, WE HAVE A MOTION.I KNOW YOU DON'T WANNA ADDRESS IT, BUT WHERE DID THAT COME FROM? UM, MOTION A SECOND FOR COMMISSIONER ANTE.
UH, WILL BE HAPPY TO COME BACK.
WE, I'LL TELL YOU THAT YOUR RECOMMENDATION, EVEN THOUGH IT WASN'T SECONDED, I ACTUALLY HEARD STAFF SAY THAT THEY COULD DO, IT JUST WASN'T SECONDED, BUT IT WAS SOMETHING THAT BASED ON I JUST PLEASE, YES.
NO GIBBS, NO VELASQUEZ, VELAZQUEZ MASUKA, NO ANTE, ANTE NAME ON? NO SIR ZER? NO.
NO A SPECIFIC AYE GIBBS NO QUE ANTE? YES.