[00:00:08]
UM, JUST QUICKLY A MESSAGE TO OUR VIRTUAL ATTENDEES.
UM, WE HAVE SEVERAL OF YOU THAT ARE PRESENTING VIRTUALLY TODAY.
UM, JUST KEEP AN EYE ON THE AGENDA WHEN YOUR CASE IS CALLED.
I'LL MAKE YOU REQUEST TO UNMUTE.
UM, TO UNMUTE, UM, PREFERABLY TURN ON YOUR VIDEO SO THAT WE CAN STATION.
UM, WITH THAT WE CAN MOVE ON TO ITEMS ON OUR AGENDA TODAY.
UM, YOU SEE WE HAVE SEVEN ITEMS ON CONSENT, UM, AND THEN ONE ANNOUNCEMENT.
ITEM 16, WHICH IS THREE IS 3 0 1 ALAMO PLAZA HAS BEEN POST BAY.
UM, SO LET'S BEGIN WITH, UH, PUBLIC COMMENTS RECEIVED FOR CONSENT ITEMS BEGINNING WITH ITEM NUMBER ONE.
THIS IS FOR AGENDA ITEM NUMBER ONE, H D R C CASE 2 0 2 3 DASH 1 1 8.
THE ADDRESS IS 3 21 CLUB DRIVE.
MY NAME IS BIANCA MALTO, CHAIR OF THE MONTICELLO PARK ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMITTEE OFFERING COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF DREA GARZA, PRESIDENT OF THE MONTICELLO PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION AND ITS NINE MEMBER BOARD OF DIRECTORS PO BOX 1 0 0 3 1 5 7 8 2 0 1.
WE SUPPORT STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THIS CASE AND WE THANK THE APPLICANT FOR COMING THROUGH THE PROCESS.
WE ONLY ASK FOR AN INCLUSION OF A STIPULATION THAT THE BRICK BE RECYCLED AND REPURPOSED IF POSSIBLE.
UH, WE THANK THE APPLICATION FOR THEIR, THE APPLICANT FOR THE INVESTMENT IN THEIR PROPERTY.
THANK YOU FOR CONSIDERATION OF OUR COMMENTS.
HELLO, MY NAME IS VALERIE CORTEZ AND I RESIDE AT FIVE EIGHT LAMAR STREET WITH DITY HILL.
I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE CONCERNED CITIZENS OF DITY HILL WITH REGARDS TO CASE NUMBER 2023 DASH 1 0 3 LOCATED AT NINE 18 NORTH PINE.
WE DO NOT AGREE WITH O P'S RECOMMENDATION FOR APPROVAL FOR THE SAME REASONS THAT O H P DID NOT RECOMMEND APPROVAL WHEN THIS CASE WAS PRESENTED TO H D R C ON FEBRUARY 15TH, 2023.
PLEASE SEE EMAIL FOR, UH, LISTINGS, RECOMMENDATION LISTINGS ONE AND TWO OF THAT PACKET.
WHILE WE APPRECIATE THE REDUCTION OF THE SIZE OF THE CARPORT FROM 74 FEET TO 56 FEET, WE DO NOT AGREE WITH THE APPROVAL OF A SIX FOOT SOLID FENCE SINCE THE FENCE WILL BE FACING NORTH PINE GUIDELINES REQUIRE THAT THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT OF FRONT YARD FENCES BE FOUR FEET AND THE MATERIAL SHOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE GUIDELINES AND HISTORIC EXAMPLES FOUND WITHIN THE DISTRICT.
[00:05:01]
APPROVED MATERIAL FOR CARPORTS AND GARAGES.THE MATERIAL SHOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE GUIDELINES FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION.
AND WHILE THE MATERIAL FOR THE WALL HAS BEEN CHANGED TO STUCCO, THIS DOES NOT MEET HISTORIC EXAMPLES FOUND WITHIN THE DISTRICT.
WE'D ALSO LIKE TO KNOW WHY THE NOTES FROM THE MARCH 21, UH, D R C SITE VISIT WERE NOT INCLUDED IN THE APPLICATION PACKET.
MY NAME IS KATHY VIC, 1 0 7 KING WILLIAMS. THIS IS IN REGARDS TO ITEM NUMBER THREE.
THE CONSERVATION SOCIETY OF SAN ANTONIO APPRECIATES THE CREATIVE AND NON-DESTRUCTIVE SOLUTIONS PROPOSED TO UPDATE THE HVAC SYSTEMS IN THE LOBBY TO BUILDINGS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE CARESS ACT.
WE SUPPORT THE O H P STAFF STIPULATIONS AND HOPE A CONSISTENT LONG-TERM MAINTENANCE PLAN FOR THESE NEW UNITS WILL BE IN PLACE TO ENSURE THAT APPROPRIATE CLIMATE CONTROL MINIMIZES MOISTURE DAMAGE TO THE STRUCTURES IN THE FUTURE.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
THIS IS FOR AGENDA ITEM NUMBER SEVEN.
THE ADDRESS IS FIVE 15 CLUB DRIVE, H C R C CASE 2 0 2 2 DASH 5 0 5.
I'M CHAIR OF MONTICELLO PARK ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMITTEE OFFERING COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF DREA GARZA, PRESIDENT OF THE MONTICELLO PARK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION AND THE MT A BOARD OF DIRECTORS PO BOX 1 0 0 3 1 5 7 8 2 0 1.
WE SUPPORT LIGHT UP AND YOU MIC IS OPEN THERE WITH THEIR STIPULATIONS.
WE THANK THE APPLICANT FOR THEIR INVESTMENT IN OUR COMMUNITY IN CONSTRUCTING THIS NEW HOME AND BEING RESPECTFUL OF OUR COMMENTS AND OUR CONCERNS THAT WE HAVE GIVEN THUS FAR IN ADDRESSING THEM IN THEIR DESIGN AND HOW THEY'RE IMPLEMENTING THEIR DESIGN.
WE DO, HOWEVER, HAVE A CAUTION FOR H C R C AND FUTURE APPLICATIONS FOR NEW CONSTRUCTIONS IN A HISTORIC DISTRICT.
ONE OF YOUR STIPULATIONS ASK THAT THE PROPERTY NOT SUCCEED UNTIL, AND YOUR MIC IS ON THAT PROPERTIES.
THE APPLICANT SUBMITTED THE PROPER DEATH DIMENSIONS FOR THEIR LOCK, HOWEVER INCORRECTLY REPRESENTED THE SETBACK OF THE ADJACENT LOT ON EITHER SIDE OF THIS PROPERTY, WHICH NOW RESULTED IN A NEW BUILDING, NEW HOME BEING BUILT ESSENTIALLY INTO THE FRONT YARD OF THE ADJACENT PROPERTIES ON BOTH SIDES.
WE THANK YOU FOR CONSIDERATION OF OUR COMMENTS AND WE WISH YOU A GREAT DAY.
PLEASE NOTE THAT THERE ARE LETTERS THAT MR. CHAIR, I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO PROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA AS UH, PRESENTED.
UH, YES WITH STAFF STIPULATIONS.
I JUST, UH, THERE'S LANGUAGE IN THE CONSENT AGENDA, BUT I'D RATHER USE, WHICH IS IN THE CONSENT AGENDA.
JUST TO BE CONSISTENT, THE CONSENT AGENDA SAYS IF ITEMS ARE PLACED ON THE CONSENT AGENDA WHEN STAFF RECOMMENDS, RECOMMENDS APPROVAL.
SO MY MOTION WOULD BE TO, TO ALSO INCORPORATE THAT INTO A MOTION TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA THAT, THAT'S ALREADY IN FOR THE CONSENT AGENDA.
AYE THAT SIR, YOU'RE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA AND YOUR ADDRESS IS 3 21 CLUB 9 2 9, UH, LATA, H V A C WORK, 42 ROOSEVELT 600 AIR THREE 12 RIDDLE AND FIVE 15 CLUB.
YOU DO NOT NEED TO STAY FOR THE REMAIN HEARING.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE FIND STAFF CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS OR COMMISSION ACTION LETTER WILL BE PREPARED AND EMAILED.
[00:10:07]
ITEM REQUEST STAFF DOES NOT RECOMMEND, STAFF DOES NOT RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF ITEM THE DRIVEWAY.STAFF RECOMMENDS APPROVAL OF ITEM TWO IN OF THE DRIVEWAY AND CURB CUT.
MR. COTTON REMOVED MR. COTTON, ARE YOU THERE? MAKE SURE YOU HAVE MUTED.
YOU HEAR ME? YES, WE CAN HEAR YOU.
MR. COTTON, YOU INTRODUCE THE DISC FIELD? WELL, WE'RE THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY AND UM, AS YOU HAD STATED EARLIER, WE ARE IN NEED TO ADD A THIRD DAY, UH, TO THE EXISTING GARAGE BUILDING.
WE ARE FLEXIBLE IN TERMS OF WHAT THE APPROACH SHOULD LOOK LIKE, SO THERE'S NO ISSUE THERE.
BUT WE DO NEED THAT THIRD BAY.
IT WILL ALLOW US TO CREATE THE DEPTH NECESSARY TO PARK A FULL-SIZED VEHICLE INSIDE THE GARAGE, WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT WE DON'T CURRENTLY HAVE NOW.
AND THAT PARTICULAR VEHICLE IS INTENDED TO, UH, PROVIDE THE TRANSPORTATION FOR A HANDICAPPED INDIVIDUAL IN THE HOUSEHOLD.
SIR, THE TWO QUESTIONS I HAVE FOR YOU, UM, ONE IS, UM, DO YOU CONSIDER THIS PROJECT AN ACCESSIBILITY PROJECT IN TERMS OF AADA IS FOR THE APPLICANT? MR. COTTON? UH, THE COMMISSIONER'S ASKING.
I I CAN HEAR THE QUESTION, BUT I, UH, I'M, I CONSIDER THIS THE ADDITION OF A GARAGE DOOR TO AN EXISTING SINGLE LEVEL BUILDING WHERE THE SPACE IS ALREADY AVAILABLE BEHIND THE, THE POINT OF ENTRY WHERE THE DOOR WOULD BE INSTALLED SO THAT WE CAN INSTALL A VEHICLE THAT IS LARGE ENOUGH TO ACCOMMODATE A HANDICAPPED INDIVIDUAL IN THE HOUSEHOLD.
CURRENTLY, THE GARAGE DEPTH ONLY ALLOWS FOR TWO VEHICLES AND IS NOT DEEP ENOUGH TO ACCOMMODATE THE VEHICLE THAT WE NEED.
SO I'M NOT SURE HOW YOU WOULD OH, YOU'RE COINING THAT, BUT COMPLAIN TO YOU WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO ACHIEVE.
SO IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THIS HEARING IS PRIMARILY HAPPENING TO DISCUSS DESIGN.
SO IS THAT, IS YOUR QUESTION FOCUSED ON THE DESIGN? UH, WELL,
[00:15:04]
MY, MY OPINION WOULD, WOULD BE MORE, WOULD BE LESS IMPORTANT WITH RESPECT TO AN ACCESSIBILITY SOLUTION THAN A DESIGN SOLUTION ALONE.SO IF IT'S A DESIGN SOLUTION ALONE, THEN FROM A DESIGN STANDPOINT, IT, IT, IT DOESN'T SEEM AS CRITICAL AS AN ACCESSIBILITY ISSUE, WHICH IS PROVIDING EQUAL ACCESS TO INDIVIDUALS IN THE HOUSEHOLD.
IT MIGHT, UH, BE UNABLE TO AFFORD THEMSELVES THE SAME, UH, ACCESSIBLE RIGHTS AS PEOPLE IN THE HOUSEHOLD WHO DO NOT HAVE ISSUES WITH ACCESSIBILITY.
SO, BUT, UH, BUT I UNDERSTAND YOUR QUESTION.
I, I YOUR ANSWER AND I APPRECIATE IT.
UM, QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT? THREE OF 'EM.
UM, WHAT HAPPENS TO, LET'S SEE, WHAT IS THE DESIGN FOR THAT DRIVEWAY CONDITION? THE SITE PLAN THAT WE SHOW THAT, UH, RIGHT OF WAY WHERE THE DRY FROM THE SEPARATED, WHAT IS THE INTENDED DESIGN FOR THAT CURB? CAN YOU HEAR US? I CAN'T HEAR YOU IF YOU'RE SPEAKING MR. COTTON.
CAN YOU, MR. CHAIR? WE CAN, WE CAN PROCEED HOWEVER YOU WANT.
MR. COTTON, CAN YOU HEAR US? MR. MR CHAIR? IF I MIGHT, IT MAY BE APPROPRIATE TO MAKE A MOTION, UM, FROM THE BRIEF PRESENTATION THAT THE APPLICANT MADE.
UH, IT, IT SEEMS THAT, THAT IT IS AN ACCESSIBLE ISSUE THAT AN ISSUE OF ACCESSIBILITY, THAT IT ISN'T THE WIDTH, WHICH IS PRIMARILY WHAT I WAS TRYING TO GET AT, WHETHER OR NOT IT WAS, UH, ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY.
'CAUSE THERE'S TWO OTHER GARAGE DOORS THERE.
BUT WITH RESPECT TO THE APPLICANT'S TESTIMONY, RIGHT, IT'S A PARTICULAR LENGTH, NOT, NOT THE WIDTH.
IF, IF, IF THIS IS THE SOLUTION THAT SATISFIES THAT LENGTH, THEN IT'S APPROPRIATE TO MAKE A MOTION TO SUPPORT THE APPLICANT'S NEED AND THAT THE APPLICANT WORK WITH STAFF TO ENSURE THAT THE EXTERIOR ELEVATION IS IN LINE WITH, WITH APPROPRIATE FACADE DESIGN.
LIKE I, I'VE IDENTIFIED THAT WE'RE NOT RECEIVING ANY AUDIO THROUGH THE WEBEX, SO HE
[00:20:02]
CAN'T, BUT, UM, SOMETHING WE WERE DOING OVER HERE WAS, I, I'M SAYING WE NEED TO POSTPONE EVERYTHING BECAUSE I DUNNO THAT THE LIVE STREAM IS GETTING ON.BUT SIR, WE DO HAVE A MOTION ON THE TABLE, RIGHT? SO WE COME BACK.
I THINK WE SHOULD REMAKE THE MOTION WHEN WE RETURN, IF THAT'S THE DESIRE.
'CAUSE THAT WAS NOT ON THE RECORD.
QUESTIONS MR. COTTON? DID YOU HEAR THE FIRST QUESTION I HAD ABOUT, UM, WHAT THE DESIGN FOR THAT CURB CUT, THE NEW CURB CUT WOULD BE, SINCE PACKAGE DOESN'T INCLUDE AN UPDATED, SO I'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT THE PLAN IS.
CURB CUT SEPARATION BETWEEN ALAN.
SO I I'M SORRY I, YOUR SOUND IS, IS BREAKING UP A BIT, SO I REALLY CAN'T HEAR YOUR QUESTION.
IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU HAD SOME QUESTIONS REGARDING CURB CUTS OR SOMETHING ELSE LIKE THAT.
WE'RE VERY FLEXIBLE IN TERMS OF CURB CUTS, PAVERS, CONCRETE ASPHALT, ALL THOSE THINGS.
OUR, OUR PRIMARY, OUR PRIMARY NEED IS JUST RELATED TO, UM, THE, THE GARAGE DOOR ITSELF.
MY CONCERN IS WHAT THAT DELINEATION BETWEEN THE PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY AND THE, YOUR DRIVEWAY, WHAT THAT IS.
AND SO WITHOUT A DESIGN IN THE PACKAGE, IT'S HARD FOR ME TO DETERMINE HOW THAT WOULD HAPPEN.
THE OTHER QUESTION I HAVE IS, SO I'M ASSUMING BY LOOKING AT THE STREET ELEVATION THAT THERE WILL BE A TREE THAT WILL BE REMOVED.
IS THAT CORRECT? SO THERE'S A CEDAR TREE NOW THAT IS, UH, GOING TO BE REMOVED EITHER BY THE CITY.
IT'S BEEN HIT A NUMBER OF TIMES BY, UH, TRASH TRUCKS SHOULD SERVICE VEHICLES.
SO I, IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THERE'S NOT AN ISSUE WITH THE TREE OKAY.
AND MY THIRD QUESTION IS, HAVE YOU HAD A CHANCE TO SPEAK WITH THE CITY REGARDING THE RELOCATION OF THE STOP WOUNDS THAT IS NEAR OR ADJACENT TO YOUR CURRENT DRIVEWAY? I, I COULDN'T UNDERSTAND YOU WELL ENOUGH.
I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'RE REFERRING TO, UH, A SIGN THAT THE CITY RECENTLY ESTABLISHED, UH, INDICATING THAT THERE WAS ANOTHER STOP SIGN THAT'S YES.
UH, IF THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE REFERRING TO.
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THE CITY INSTALLED THAT BECAUSE A TREE HAD TO BE REMOVED ON A NEIGHBOR'S PROPERTY, UH, THAT SITS BEHIND US.
HAVE YOU VISITED WITH, HAVE YOU SPOKEN WITH THE CITY ABOUT RELOCATING THAT SUN TO ALLOW YOU UH, I'M SORRY, I JUST COULDN'T, I CAN'T HEAR YOU WELL ENOUGH.
HAVE YOU SPOKEN WITH I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY, I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY QUESTION IN TERMS OF PRECEDENT.
HADN'T BEEN SET FOR, UH, VEHICLES THAT HAVE THREE AND FOUR GARAGE BAYS.
UH, WE SHARED SOME PHOTOS WITH THE CITY WHEN THIS HEARING WAS SET UP A FEW WEEKS AGO.
UH, SHOWING MULTIPLE SITES WITHIN THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE, UH, SIMILAR, UM, UH, BUILDINGS ARE DEVELOPED IN THAT WAY.
UH, SPECIFICALLY BUILDINGS THAT SIT, UH, RIGHT, UH, ON, ON TOP OF, UH, OF AN ALLEY.
THAT'S, UM, THE END OF MY QUESTIONS.
I HAVE QUESTION FOR CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR, OUR SETBACK DOES NOT SIDE YARD SETBACKS.
SECOND STORY, HAVE YOU ADDRESS MAY SIR, OR ARE YOU AWARE OF THESE OR YEAH, I, I'M SORRY.
I, I I CAN'T, I REALLY CAN'T HEAR WHAT YOU'RE SAYING.
THERE WAS SOUNDS LIKE SOME COMMENTARY AND SOME DISCUSSIONS AND MAYBE A, A QUESTION.
BUT THE DESIGN ITSELF, IF YOU LOOK AT THAT, IT, IT SPEAKS FOR ITSELF.
UM, IT IS, IT IS SIMPLY JUST THE ADDITION OF THE GARAGE DOOR ON, ON THAT CORNER OF THE BUILDING.
[00:25:01]
NO OTHER CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH WHAT HAS ALREADY BEEN APPROVED WITH THE SECOND FLOOR OR THE OVERHANG OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.WE ARE EXTREMELY, UH, UH, FLEXIBLE IN TERMS OF DESIGN.
UM, AGAIN, OUR REQUEST IS TO, UM, INSTALL AND ENTER THAT GARAGE AND, AND PUT IN A LARGER VEHICLE TO ACCOMMODATE A HANDICAPPED, UH, HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.
AND SO IF WITH REGARD TO ANY DESIGN ISSUES OR CONCERNS ABOUT, UH, THE COLOR OF THE DOOR OR AN OVERHANG OR WHERE A CURVE IS PLACED OR NOT, AGAIN, WE'RE VERY FLEXIBLE.
UM, AND WE'LL BE HAPPY TO ACCOMMODATE WHAT CITY STAFF RECOMMENDS.
MR. CHAIR, I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE, UH, APPLICANT'S REQUEST AS SUBMITTED WITH STIPULATION THAT, UH, THE APPLICANT BE REQUIRED TO COORDINATE COLORS AND DOOR TYPE WITH STAFF.
SO LET'S ADD, UM, WORKING WITH STAFF TO COORDINATE CURB, UH, UH, CURB CUT AS REQUIRED, IT AS REQUIRED IF AS REQUIRED, AND, UH, SURFACE MATERIAL.
UM, ON THIS CASE, I, IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, I THINK THAT CONTEXT IS VERY IMPORTANT AND PRIMARILY BECAUSE THERE ARE TWO RESIDENTIAL FRONTAGES DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET.
I FEEL LIKE A THREE CAR DRIVE WITH OR DRIVEWAYS ON THE OTHER SIDE.
AND IT WAS CLEAR THAT THE USE ON STREET WAS ONE ABOUT ACCESS AND CIRCULATION.
UM, I COULD SEE AN EXCEPTION FOR THIS CASE, THIS PARTICULAR CASE, WE HAVE NEIGHBORS WITH THEIR FRONT LOTS, FRONT DOORS DIRECTLY ACROSS FROM THE DRIVEWAY.
SO, UM, WE DON'T SEE THIS SITUATION ELSEWHERE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD IN THIS PER SITUATION.
FOR THAT REASON, I WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO SUPPORT THIS REQUEST.
UH, AS I LOOK AT THIS, UM, I DON'T HAVE AN ISSUE WITH ADDING, I GUESS I, I'M IN AGREEMENT WITH THE STAFF RECOMMENDED, BASED ON WHAT HAS BEEN PRESENTED THUS FAR, NO ISSUE WITH ADDING A THIRD, A THIRD GARAGE DOOR.
AND IT APPEARS CLEAR TO ME THAT THE APPLICANT IS VERY WILLING TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT COMPLIES WITH ALL THE GUIDELINES.
AND SO I HAVE NO CONCERNS THERE.
BUT FROM AN ENGINEER'S PERSPECTIVE, WHEN I LOOK AT THE ORIENTATION OF THIS GARAGE AND IT'S ONLY 20 FEET DEEP, A STANDARD GARAGE WITH A GARAGE, AND, UM, THIS DOESN'T, THIS DESIGN DOESN'T GIVE YOU THAT AND PROBABLY NONE OF OUR BUSINESS, UH, WHETHER THAT, WHETHER INDIVIDUAL WHO HAS ACCESS IS GONNA BE THE PASSENGER.
BUT ADDING THE, A THIRD BAY ON THE LEFT HAND SIDE WITH SOLID WALL AND, AND ON THE BACKSIDE OF THAT GARAGE IS WHERE THE PROPOSED SPIRAL STAIRCASE COMES IN.
I'M NOT SURE THAT IT PROVIDES THE, THE DIMENSIONS FOR, FOR ACCESS ON THAT LEFT SIDE.
AND, AND SO FOR THAT REASON, I DON'T KNOW THAT YOU WOULD EVER NEED A THIRD WIDENED DRIVEWAY TO BUY THAT ACCIDENT.
HOW, HOW THE, THE VEHICLE THAT THAT WOULD BE CARRYING THE PASSENGER ACCIDENT WITH ACCESS.
IT'S NOT CLEAR TO ME HOW THAT'S HOW THIS DESIGN IS GOING SOLVE THAT AND THEREFORE I DON'T KNOW THAT IT NEEDS WHITEY GI
[00:30:01]
NAY.VELAZQUEZ ZUKA CARPENTER GROUP ANTE? YES.
THAT'S AGENDA ITEM NUMBER NINE H DRC CASE NUMBER 20 23 7 3 0 6 BELL MAP PLACE THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS FOR APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT A SECOND STORY ADDITION ON TOP OF AN EXISTING ADDITION TO THE EXISTING HISTORIC STRUCTURE ON SITE.
THE LOT ADDRESS AS 3 0 6 BELL MAP PLACE WAS ONCE PART OF THE PROPERTY ADDRESS AS THREE WEST PLACE.
STAFF RECOMMENDS APPROVAL BASED ON FINDINGS A THROUGH L WITH THE FOLLOWING STIPULATIONS.
ONE THAT THE APPLICANT MODIFIED THE PROPOSED SHED ROOF TO FEATURE A HIP ROOF CONSISTENT WITH THOSE FOUND HISTORICALLY ON SITE AND GUIDELINES AS NOTED IN FINDINGS.
TWO, THAT THE APPLICANT INSTALL ROOFING MATERIALS THAT ARE CONSISTENT WITH GUIDELINES AS NOTED IN FINDING G THREE THAT THE APPLICANT INSTALLS WINDOWS THAT FEATURE PROFILES THAT ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE GUIDELINES AND HISTORICALLY WITHIN THE DISTRICT.
AND THAT ALL WINDOWS ADHERE TO THE ADOPTED POLICY FOR WINDOWS FOUR THAT THE APPLICANT PROPOSED RAILING.
THE PROPOSED THAT DETAILS RAILING AND COLUMNS REVIEW AND APPROVAL IS NOTED IN K E L.
THE APPLICANT IS HERE IN PERSON.
GARAGE ATTACHED BY A WALL TO STRUCTURE.
IT'S JUST A HALF LENGTH OF ALL THAT STUFF EXCEPT THE PROBLEM BECAUSE THE ROOF IS DESIGNED THE WAY IT WILL PREVENT ADDITIONAL WATERSHED TO OUR NEIGHBORS.
WE'RE ALSO STRUCTURE ROOF TILE THAT WOULD ALSO MATCH WITH HISTORIC STRUCTURAL RIGHTS, RIGHT? ALL THAT STUFF MATCHES THE HISTORIC STRUCTURE COMPLETELY.
AND THE ADDITIONAL FENCING OF GRATES OR HAS BEEN TWICE, NOT THE PICTURES BUT THERE ORNAMENTAL WE ACTUALLY HAVE FROM PROJECTS AND STUFF TO WE THERE.
QUESTION SAYING ALREADY ABOUT BUILDING GARAGE IS IT HAS, ITS, IS IT A ZERO LOCK? OH SO THIS IS A ZERO IS PRETTY CLOSE.
THERE'S SCREEN RIGHT NOW THAT IT MAYBE GIVES YOU A LITTLE BIT BETTER IDEA.
[00:35:03]
OPENING RIGHT ON THE LINE.THAT RED LINE, BOTTOM RED LIGHT RIGHT THERE, RIGHT BUILDING IS ON THE LOT LINE WHERE SAY LESS THAN FOOT.
WE, WE DON'T WANNA SHED TOO MUCH WATER THAT'S FINED RATHER NOT MODIFY PROBLEMS. SECOND GIBBS.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR, THANK YOU FOR BEARING WITH US.
UM, SO WHAT WE HAVE REALIZED WAS HAPPENING UP TO WHERE TYPED DOWN TO WEBSITE, WHERE THE LIVE STREAM PLACE WEBEX USERS, WHICH APPLICANTS ON THE LEFT, THEY COULD ONLY THAT WAS BEING FROM THAT COMPUTER MIC.
AND SO HOW FAR AWAY YOU'RE LAPTOP THE RECORD DOES NOT RECOMMEND STAFF RECOMMENDS THE APPLICANT ADDRESS ITEM PRIOR TO AND THAT INCLUDES 14 STIPULA.
IS THERE A WAY TO, IS THERE A WAY TO DESCRIBE IN A SHORTER FASHION? STAFF DOES NOT RECOMMEND SET SETBACK DIAGRAMS, HEIGHT DIAGRAMS, LOT C MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS THAT MEETS STAFF STANDARDS? DO THEY SIMPLIFY THE PROPOSED MATERIAL PALETTE? UH, THE PROPOSED WINDOW SIZES, PATTERNS, PROPORTION BUILT DETAILING THAT ARE CONSISTENT GUIDELINES THAT THE NEW CONSTRUCTION, CORPORATE ARCHITECTURAL OF CONTEXT AND ARE CONSISTENT WITH GUIDELINES.
UH, THAT THE PORCH ENTRY AREA THAT IS THAT THE DRIVEWAY SHOULD NOT EXCEED 10 WIDTH AND COMPLY WITH THE FOUR LINE GUIDELINES THAT THE APPLICANT SUBMITS MATERIAL SPECIFIC
[00:40:01]
TO THE FRONT WALKWAY, NOT EXCEED WIDTH AND ELEMENTS SPECIFIC FOR THE PROPOSED GARAGE DOOR IS HIRED TO AND THE APPLICANT IS WITH WILL THE BAR AS WELL.HELLO? YES, PAUL, BEFORE YOU BEGIN, UH, THE APPLICANT HAS ALSO SUBMITTED, UPDATED, NOT PUBLISHED SINCE WE HAVE NOT BEEN REVIEWED BY STAFF AND NOT IN THE RECOMMENDATIONS, BUT STAFF IS ABLE TO MR. CHAIR IN THE INTEREST OF TIME AND CLARITY, IT, IT, IT MAY BE PRUDENT TO TO HEAR A MOTION TO CONTINUE OR TO GO TO A CONSULTATION BECAUSE THE, IF THE APPLICATION BEFORE US IS A FOR CONCEPTUAL STAFF'S REQUIREMENTS GO BEYOND CONCEPTUAL.
ALTHOUGH THERE ARE SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS THAT ARE, THAT ARE MADE BY STAFF THAT ARE CONSISTENTLY CONCEPTUAL SUCH AS HEIGHTS AND UM, PROPER DIAGRAMS. BUT THEN WE GET INTO THE WINDOWS AND THINGS LIKE THAT, THEY'RE DEFINITELY NOT PART OF CONCEPTUAL CONSIDERATION.
MAYBE THERE NEEDS TO BE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR STAFF TO REVIEW THE, THE, THE DIAGRAMS THAT CAME IN AND FOR THERE DEVIATION AS TO WHAT THE APPLICANT IS NOW UNDERSTANDING CONSTITUTES CO CONCEPT.
I WOULD, I WOULD SAY SO I WOULD MOVE SECOND GIBBS AYE.
APPLICANT'S REQUEST, CERTIFICATE, APPROPRIATENESS, STAFF NOT RECOMMEND WINDOWS ON FINDING THE APPLICANT.
HEAR YOU IN TRANSLATING WE CAN'T HEAR YOU.
YOU GOTTA BE IN AND THEN YOU CAN TRANSLATE.
[00:45:20]
STAFF WAS NOT ABLE TO CONDUCT A, A SITE VISIT.THE APPLICANTS ARE NOT AVAILABLE FOR THE SITE VISIT CERTAIN, HOWEVER, IN PREVIOUS, UM, PREVIOUS HEARING STAFF DID CONDUCT A SITE VISIT AND THERE WERE NO, THE APPLICANT DID NOT PROVIDE SPECIFICATIONS.
SO WHEN IT COMES TO THE PROCESS, UM, I
[00:51:23]
[00:57:08]
IT'S, WE THE BEST PRO.SO THEY DID COME OVER, THEY MADE THE AC MORE VERY COLD DURING THE WINTER MONTHS AND WE HAVE TO SHOOT UP THE, THE HEATER OR AIR UNALIKE UNBEARABLY HOT
[01:02:22]
WITH SEVERAL[01:05:05]
THE, THE, THE, UM, SECOND LEVEL PROVIDE EXTRA OPPORTUNITY FOR THERE TO BE VISUAL CONNECTION GRADE, BUT ALSO EFFICIENCY HERE.
THAT SOLUTION MS, IT WAS SYRIA AND UH, AND THEN AND UM, AND THEN ON THE SOUTHWEST SIDE,
[01:11:30]
TENNIS MENTO.I MEAN LAURA, THE COST WENT FROM BEN.
I MUCH JUST FOR THE, THE REPAIR HAS BEEN UM, AYE.
[01:15:13]
MOTION FAILS.IT'S AND ITEM C UNDER CIA CONVERSATIONS.
[01:20:07]
DE LA.SO EL PADO HERE THAT, UM, RO OKAY.
MOTION CARRIES LOWER AND WEBEX ONLINE.
THIS IS, I JUST WANT FOR THESE, UM, I'M UNDERTAKING A HUGE PROJECT WITH THIS HOUSE AS I'M SURE MAYBE YOU GUYS, UM, I LOVE TO RESTORE ALL INVENTORY ALREADY.
THE FACT THAT I ALREADY HELPS WITH MY BUDGET
[01:25:01]
AND THAT THEN THAT WOULD BE GREAT.BUT UM, I JUST WANNA REITERATE AND UH, THIS IS LANGUAGE.
THE REAR WINDOWS SLIDING SIGNIFICANT DEFENDANT, UM, NO UPSTAIRS.
UM, NO, THERE'S NO, IT'S JUST NO I NOIAN.
[01:30:04]
THANK YOU GUYS.I DON'T, CAN'T SAY AGU AFTERNOON.
UM, IRENE, THE FIVE ONE WITH LOCUS ON BLOCK, THE ST.
THE AND THAT DISREGARD CONDITION, THE, I'M STILL CALLING THE
WHICH PRESCRIPTION? THE ACQUA DESCRIPTION AT WHAT THE COST.
[01:35:06]
THEY'RE WOOD WINDOWS.UM, AUNTIE WAS AND A UM, MARY.
YEAH, MAINTENANCE TANGO'S PARENTS ARE THERE ION
[01:40:29]
FROM THE STANDPOINT.SO MARY'S SISTER
[01:47:44]
UM, CHEAPER.UM, ANY OTHER THINGS? ION PROTECTION.
[01:51:31]
TO THE IMPORTANT, IT'S LIKE HISTORIC CAPITAL SMES.[01:56:10]
ANTONIO, UM, PRESERVATIONS.[02:01:55]
I RECOMMEND CORNELL.SO WHAT, OKAY, SO WAS AROUND THE HELLO
[02:05:14]
KNOW THIS UPON ANOTHER AREA.SO MENT LOS FLORES, WE EFFECTFULLY REQUEST
[02:10:07]
THE PUBLIC RIGHT, 88 SIDE WORK.THAT'S AN INTERNAL WATER SYSTEM.
ONLY THING I'M DO IS OKAY, QUESTION IS PREVENTION.
[02:17:42]
CONSIDER, OKAY.[02:20:25]
CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES.IS LOCATED THE HOUSE WAS A HOUSE THAT LA PROPERTY THAT WEST.
UM, WELL HE HAS A YARD, EIGHT VEHICLES.
THE BACK TOP BOTTOM OF WHERE, WHERE THE RIGHT OF THE FENCE IS.
SO YOU CAN SEE I DID A THE FRONT, THE HOME THAT'S ESA.
YOU GUYS HEAR HIM ART ME HISTORICAL IN THIS AREA.
QUESTION WOULD YOU THE SIDE, THERE IS A
[02:25:14]
UM, UM, THE, THE CORNER RIGHT THERE THAT'S SEE TRAFFIC THAT THE FRONT YARD.SO I DIDN'T WANNA PUT FENCE THE FRONT BECAUSE WRAP AROUND FENCE.
THE FRONT OF HOUSE AS PROTECTION.
SO THAT FENCE STARTS ON THE OF BACKYARD.
[02:30:09]
MOTION PASS.TIM ROGERS THE LADY, THE CAM LESBIAN ACTUALLY QUESTIONS, UH, CATHERINE APPROVAL OF THE PROP DESIGN.
[02:35:02]
NEEDS TO BE ALSO, IT SAYS THOSE STRUCTURES TRO YES.[02:40:27]
FAMILY HOME, CONSIDER A SINGLE HOME.[02:45:04]
ION THERE IT'S A PROJECTOR, FIRE DEPARTMENT THERE.IT ALSO CREATES SOMETHING THAT TECHNICALLY ONE CONDO BUT STILL
[02:50:02]
COMPLEX.NO, IF WE RECOMMEND THAT, MAY MAY RECOMMEND THAT.
WELL, I, WE CONCEPTUAL, UM, ECONOMIC THE MORE JUST THE, UH, THE DISTANCE CENTER AO AL, EL PA, UM, THE CONFLICTION.
I RECOMMEND THAT THE R C, THE REVISION, UH, AND SENIOR CHAIRMAN
[02:55:02]
BENEFICIAL YOUR SUPPORT AREA.WHAT I'VE SEEN IS THAT ACCESSIBLE.
[03:01:25]
HEY GUYS, UH, I SAY THIS AROUND PORCH KIND OF DESIGN ON THE, FROM IT'S INSIDE WRAP AROUND ANYMORE ALSO AND FOR SINGLE FAMILY.[03:06:52]
OH, OKAY.AND THEN MM-HMM
[03:10:11]
MA'AM.SO, SO, SO INCONSISTENCY HERE, THE PATIENT NOT MATCHING, RIGHT? YES.
AND OKAY, ELLAN, DISCOVER THIS PICTURE.
UM, THIS PART HERE IS ACTUALLY, SO, AND ALL THIS DO YOU, THIS CASE NOT 11 FOUR CEILINGS IN THIS SECOND HERE, THE PORCH,
[03:16:11]
A SOLUTION TO UH, UH, OFFICIAL THE ANTIGUA[03:20:24]
ON THE UP TO CHAIRMAN.