* This transcript was created by voice-to-text technology. The transcript has not been edited for errors or omissions, it is for reference only and is not the official minutes of the meeting. [00:00:15] COMMISSIONER ALBERTAN AKI. COMMISSIONER VASQUEZ. SI. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. IBANEZ. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. DEAN. PRESENT. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. AKI. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. SUNGA. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. ANA. COMMISSIONER. VID. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. BRAMAN. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. KAPLAN. PRESENT. COMMISSIONER. ORANGE. CHAIR. ORIAN. PRESIDENT. ORIAN. CHAIR. ORIAN. PRESIDENT OR S [00:06:51] INTERSECTION. [00:10:12] SO MR. INDUSTRIAL. INDUSTRIAL. C. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. QUEZ. VASQUEZ. ODIN. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. BRAMAN. LOS LOS SYSTEMS. [00:18:43] AM [00:24:21] ME [00:26:14] LIKE, UH, LAS CONFLICT. [00:35:24] PARA. [00:36:13] YES. CON CON. COMMISSIONER BARRINGTON CON. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER VASQUEZ. CON COMMISSIONER. DEAN CON. COMMISSIONER CRUZ CON. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER CONMAN CON OR CAN YOU UNMUTE YOURSELF PLEASE? CAN YOU INDICATE MARTIN STREET? [00:41:17] UM, COMMISSIONER CRUZ AND PARK IN NATALIE MEDINA STREET, RIVER WALK. [00:48:54] BROADWAY STREET. [00:51:59] THE [00:55:26] SANCHEZ STILL IN SAN ANTONIO. [01:00:24] KENNEDY IS LA CALLING PATH. NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO. . NATALIE? NO. KAPLAN. RIO. [01:06:30] GRA MS. KAPLAN. MSN ESO PERSONAL? [01:10:05] UH, NO. NO, NO, NO, NO. JACOB RECOMMEND RECOMMENDS VASQUEZ. DEAN. NO. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. COMMISSIONER. YEAH. YES. [01:16:29] DUPLEX. [01:22:12] ROSA ROMERO. MORALES. [01:27:50] KAPLAN CON COMMISSIONER BRAMAN CON. COMMISSIONER VAZQUEZ CON CON. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER CRUZ CONCOR. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER SUNGA CON. [01:30:13] MARTINEZ. MARTINEZ. CARLOS MARTINEZ. CARLOS MARTINEZ. THE [01:38:27] MONEY [01:41:28] CONDITION. KAPLAN VASQUEZ. COMMISSIONER ES COMMISSIONER CRUZ C ES. COMMISSIONER ESMAN ES STREET AVENUE. [01:45:58] I JUST AVENUE. I [01:52:14] PERMIT AVENUE. [01:55:01] AVENUE. UM, CRUZ CON, CAPTAIN CON BARRINGTON CON CON CON COMMISSIONER BLANK STREET [02:03:30] IMPLEMENTED, [02:05:31] YOU KNOW. OKAY. ONE OF THE LAST. KAPLAN [02:12:46] CON CRUZ. CON CON C CON [02:15:23] HARON CO. THE POWERPOINT. SO LAUREN SCHNEIDER POWERPOINT, THE THE DSPS, [02:20:11] METALLICA, UH, CRIMINAL, THE SPOT CRIME. AND METALLICA. THE METALLICA IS THOSE RESOLUTION ACCEPTING [02:26:37] DERA. [02:32:10] THE S IN NORTH HAR CONDITION [02:35:39] CON VASQUE. COMMISSIONER CRUZ COMM. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER. COMMISSIONER ORIAN KAPLAN. NO. NO. GON GONZALEZ PLACE. SAN ANTONIO [02:48:50] QUE [02:48:52] CRUZ CON CON CON KAPLAN CON ENGINEERING [02:50:02] AND NORTH, NORTH NEW BRUMFIELD AVENUE, OAK PARK, NORTHWOOD. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. SO ASHLEY, HAPPY HOMES AND RECHO IS ASHLEY MARSH? [03:03:08] YES. [03:03:11] TO PROJECTO. I [03:05:56] GABRIEL SAYS SUNSET COURT IN SAN ANTONIO. LYDIA RODRIGUEZ. SAN ANTONIO KIM GAS SOY KIM GUEST AND M AND CUL-DE-SAC. THE COURT, MS. MAN [03:10:11] SAC CHARACTER, [03:15:18] MASS [03:20:56] OPPOSITION IS TO [03:25:01] ANYTHING HOT. SO MARIA CLARK IS [03:32:58] OKAY. [03:39:29] ALEXANDER. SO ALEXANDER EXPIRES. RICHARD MENTIONED [03:45:28] INSPECTION [03:46:20] FOR COURT. COMMISSIONER QUE CRUZ KAPLAN CHOSE RENA DS KAPLAN. [03:51:22] HOLD ON JUST A SECOND, MA'AM. UH, MR. CHAIR, WE JUST REALIZED THAT THE INTERPRETERS HAVE TO LEAVE BY A CERTAIN TIME, WHICH MEANS THE, THE SPANISH SPEAKING, UH, CUSTOMER IS NOT GONNA BE ABLE TO BE, UM, HEARD. SO IF WE CAN PAUSE AND BRING UP THAT LAST CASE, UH, IT WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED. BE ITEM NUMBER 16. SORRY ASHLEY. ALRIGHT, UM, ITEM NUMBER 16, BO 8 23 1 3 3 44 LOCATED AT 8 31 ANGELA STREET, DISTRICT FIVE APPLICANT BEING GABRIEL MENDOZA. WE REQUEST FOR THREE FOOT NINE NAMES OF VARIANT IN MINIMUM FIVE FOOT SIDE SETBACK TO ALLOW A ONE FOOT THREE INCH SIDE SETBACK. ZONED MF 33 PROBABLY LOCATED BETWEEN SAN HAMILTON AVENUE AND SOUTH WEST. JUST WEST OF DOWNTOWN. THE, THE AREA PREDOMINANTLY ZONED MULTIFAMILY SINGLE. THE APPLICANT DEVELOPED A SINGLE BACK OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE SETBACK IS A A NEIGHBOR SIDE PLAN. SO SET BACK FRONT OF THE PROPERTY SIDE FROM THE FRONT. SO THIS IS TAKEN FROM THE REAR. THIS IS THE CLOSEST PORT OF THE SIDE SETBACK. I KNOW WE ADVERTISED FOR ONE INCH SIDE SETBACK. UH, WE DID THAT. JUST CAPTURED EVERYTHING WE COULD. SO THE ACTUAL SETBACK IS GONNA BE FOOTS THREE INCHES. STRUCTURE IS TWO FOOT THREE INCHES. ROUNDING AREA SET NOW IN B3. FOUR BASED ON FOLLOWING VARIANCE, CONTRARY TO THE PUBLIC INTEREST AND TO REDUCED SETBACK AND PROPERTY, UH, 52 NOTICES WERE MAILED OUT AND DEEMED IN OPPOSITION FAVOR AND NO. AND I WILL ADD THAT THIS PROPERTY WAS RECENTLY DEMOLISHED AND BECAUSE IT WAS TOTALLY DEMOLISHED THE NON PERFORMING WHETHER AND THE APPLICANT IS AVAILABLE FOR, THEY, THEY ACTUALLY ARE. YEAH, IT, IT'S KIND OF A UNIQUE SITUATION. THERE WAS ONE WALL THAT WAS STILL UP AND SO THEY JUST WENT THERE AND THEN THE FORWARD, UM, AND WHEN THE INSPECTOR WENT OUT TO INSPECT, FOUND THAT, OH NO, IT, SO THAT'S WHY THEY'RE HERE TODAY. BUT THEY ARE BUILDING WHERE THE FOOTPRINT ACTUALLY THERE WAS ACTUALLY ONE WALL THERE THAT IS EXACTLY THE SAME WALL FROM THERE. [03:55:02] THEY DID. THEY DID. THEY DID. CORRECT. MY NAME IS GIO, I'M THE CONTRACTOR PROPERTY AND WE JUST WANTED TO VERIFY ABOUT THE SPANISH SPEAKING. DO WE NEED SOME MONEY? HE'S A PROPERTY OWNER, I BELIEVE. DOES HE WANNA SAY SOMETHING SO THAT WE CAN BRING THE, BECAUSE THEIR, THEIR SCHEDULE IS, SORRY. LET'S SEE IF WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR YOU. NO COMMENTS. SORRY. OH, STAFF YOU'RE SAYING THAT HE BUILDING THIS HOME WAS ONE OF THE WALLS THAT WAS STILL THERE, CORRECT? THAT'S CORRECT. OKAY. SO WE'RE JUST DOING THE REAR ENDS BECAUSE HE BUILT IT TOO CLOSE TO THE NEIGHBOR. UH, BECAUSE IT'S ALREADY TOO CLOSE. IT WAS ALREADY TOO CLOSE TO THE NEIGHBORS. WELL IT'S NOT CONFORMED, BUT SINCE HE DESTROYED OVER 50% OF THE STRUCTURE OF THE FOOTPRINTS, THE, THERE'S A PICTURE THAT SHOWS YOU AND THEY JUST, THEY, THEY STARTED WITH WITH WHAT WAS LEFT AND WENT FROM THERE. AND THEN IT WASN'T UNTIL THE INSPECTOR WENT OUT TO INSPECT THE FRAMING THAT THEY REALIZED THAT IT WAS TOO DID SAY ANYTHING SLOW NEIGHBORS THAT STUFF. SO YOU, YOU THAT YOU'RE, IT'S A REQUIREMENT AND I CAN CONFIRM THAT THEY HAVEN'T. YES, [04:02:01] I CONCUR WITH MY COLLEAGUE. I WAS WITH ALL THE ADDITIONS THAT HE'S DOING. I DON'T SEE A PROBLEM WITH STRUCTURAL POSITION. NOT RECOGNIZED. COMMISSIONER BRAGMAN. COMMISSIONER CRUZ. I CONCUR. COMMISSIONER BARRINGTON. I CONCUR. YES, I CONCUR. COMMISSIONER DEAN. COMMISSIONER ZUNIGA. THUMBS UP. MR. ZUNIGA. COMMISSIONER ANA. COMMISSIONER AVI. COMMISSIONER KAPLAN. I CONCUR. COMMISSIONER ORIAN, CHAIR. ZUNA. SECOND. MR. CHAIR, I'M GONNA GO AHEAD AND, I'M SORRY, SAY THAT AGAIN. I'M GONNA HAVE TO GO TOSO. OKAY. NEITHER ONE OF YOU CAN STAY FOR, FOR THIS CASE. WE HAVE HER TWO MORE CASES. TWO CASES. THANK YOU. LIKE YOU LIKE ICE CREAM. OKAY. GRIFFIN, THE SOUTH FOREST ROAD [04:06:10] INDUSTRIAL. I VARIANCE. [04:11:40] PACIFIC SICO. 16. METALLICA. OKAY. MS. RAGMAN. [04:16:23] YE. IS IT WORKING? COMMISSIONER BRAGMAN. COMMISSIONER KAMAN. I CONCUR. I CONCUR. DEAN. COMMISSIONER ZUNIGA. COMMISSIONER NER HERE WITH THE DEFENSE COMMISSIONER. BEEZ. COMMISSIONER ORIAN. COMMISSIONER ZUNIGA. THUMBS UP CHAIR. ZUNA? YES. UM, YOU OH MS. CRUZ. I'M SORRY. I CONCUR. AND LAST CASE. THANK YOU. UM, FILE IS 8 23 0 3 7 LOCATED AT TEXAS DISTRICT 10. APPLICANT BEING GABRIEL MENDOZA. REQUEST FOR A SEVEN SIX VARI FOR THE MINIMUM 10 FOOT FRONT SETBACK TO ALLOW TWO FOOT SIX INCH FRONT CARPORT, SETBACK AND A THREE FOOT SIDE. THREE FOOT VARI FOR THE MINIMUM FIVE FOOT SIDE SETBACK TO ALLOW TWO FOOT SIDE SETBACK ZONED R FOUR RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY. SO THEY'RE PROBABLY LOCATED JUST SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF BANDERA ROAD IN NORTH GENERAL MULLEN DRIVE LOCATED IN THE WOODLAWN LAKE RESIDENTIAL AREA. THE PROPERTY IS ADDED TO THE EXISTING, ADDED TO THE EXISTING CARPORT. PROVIDE ADDITIONAL ROOM ON CARPORT. THE CURRENT CARPORT CAN FIT TWO VEHICLES ADDITIONAL. PROVIDE COVER PARKING FOR TWO ADDITIONAL VEHICLES. PROPERTY OWNER BEGAN FILLING THE ADDIT TO CAR WITHOUT A PERMIT BUT WAS STOP BY, CITED BY CO COMPLIANCE. IT IS THE SITE PLAN SHOWING THE ADDITION TO THE CARPORT AND FRONT PROPERTY CARPORT SURROUNDING AREA STAFF RECOMMEND THAT NOW ON 23 7 BASED ON THE FOLLOWING VARIANCE DISTRICT AND SETBACK AND THE APPROPRIATE PROPERTIES AND DAMAGE CAN BE CAUSED TO THE NEIGHBORING YARD AND THE BACK WILL BE INTRODUCED. ANY NOTICES WERE MAILED OUT? NO. RESPOND. THEY WERE [04:20:07] COMPLIANCE CONSTRUCTION. THE THANK YOU. YOUR, YOU HAVE A CONTRACT THAT YOUR GUIDANCE, RIGHT? I KNOW ONE BIG ISSUE QUESTION. SO I GUESS THE QUESTION, IF I DRIVE THROUGH THE COMMUNITY, THAT MANY CAR, SO WHAT IS THE DISTANCE FOR THAT POLE TO THE SO COMING FROM THAT FRONT POLE HAVE YEAH, THE REST POINT THERE AP GENERALLY THAT'S THE START OF PROPERTY. SO, SO AS I DRIVE THROUGH THE COMMUNITY, I SEE SEVERAL THAT ARE CLOSER TO LIKE FIVE FEET AWAY. AND I GUESS THE QUESTION I'D ASK IF, IF WE ASKED YOU TO MOVE IT FIVE FOOT BACK, THAT AN FIVE FEET. SO, SO PART OF THE DIALOGUE ABOUT FIVE. SO THE OVER, SO THE OVERHANG, UH, THEY PUSH YOU TO FIVE FEET, THE OVERHANG AND GO WEST. SO DOES THAT MAKE SENSE WHAT I'M SAYING? SO IF WE PUSH THE PULLS BACK A LITTLE BIT, YOU STILL CAN HAVE, STILL PROVIDE MORE SHADE. COMMISSIONER, CAN YOU USE YOUR MICROPHONE? ONE THAT'S CLOSEST TO ROAD WHAT YOUR SKID. IF YOU PUSH THAT BACK FIVE FEET TO LIKE WHERE THE CAR IS, YOU CAN THEN HAVE A TWO FOOT OVERHANG. MEANING, SO EVEN THOUGH YOU PUSH IT BACK FIVE FEET, YOU'RE REALLY ONLY LOSING THREE FEET AND, AND YOU'LL DO GUTTERS. PRINT CARPORT. YEAH. CARPORT. NO. WOULD LIKE TO HAVE ANYTHING BEFORE. [04:25:35] THANK YOU. GREAT, THANK YOU SIR. LET'S SEE IF WE UH, WOULD I CAN MANNA MANNA, MANNA MANNA REGARDING CASE NUMBER BO A 2 3 1 0 3 0 0 3 3 7. THE BOARD ADJUSTMENT BRANCH REQUEST FOR A FIVE FOOT VARIANCE FOR THE MINIMUM 10 FOOT FRONT SETBACK TO ALLOW A FIVE FOOT FRONT CARPORT, SETBACK, MR. D AND THREE FOOT VARIANCE FROM THE MINIMUM FIVE FOOT SIDE SETBACK TO ALLOW TWO FOOT CARPORT SIDE SETBACK WITH A CARPORT. TWO INCLUDE GUTTERS SITUATED AT 2, 2, 4 5 TEXAS AVENUE APPLICANT BEING GABRIEL MENDOZA BECAUSE TESTIMONY PRESENTED TO US THE FACTS THAT WE HAVE DETERMINED TO SHOW THAT THE PHYSICAL CHARACTER OF THIS PROPERTY ENFORCEMENT VISION TO THE EEC AS RESULT UNNECESSARY SPECIFICALLY FIND THAT ONE OF THE VARIANCES REQUEST WOULD NOT BE CONTRARY ROOM ON THE SIDE IN FRONT OF THE PROPERTY FOR ANY MAINTENANCE SEPARATIONS DUE TO SPECIAL CONDITIONS. ENFORCEMENT OF THE GOOD RESULT, NOT NECESSARY PROFESSIONAL CONDITIONS, EXISTING PROPERTY, NOT SUFFICIENT ENOUGH SPACE FOR CARPORT TO COVER THE PROPERTY. THREE, BY GRANTING THE VARIANCE THE ORDINANCE WILL BE THE ORDINANCE IS TO PROVIDE SEPARATION. THE ADDITION TO THE CARPORT, IT BUTS THE NEIGHBORS OPEN YARD. WITNESS FOUR OF THE VARIANCE WILL NOT AUTHORIZE THE OPERATIONAL USE. OTHER AUTHORIZE NO USES OTHER THAN THOSE ALLOWED WITHIN THE DISTRICT WILL BE ALLOWED BY SUCH VARIANCE, WILL NOT SEIZE THE PROPERTY OR ALTER THE CHARACTER OF THE DISTRICT IN WHICH GRANTED THE VARIANCE REQUEST NOT PROPERTIES. NOT AS THERE NOT A TRUCTURE ION SIX OWNER OF THE PROPERTY FOR WHICH VARIANCE DUE TO UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES, THE PROPERTY UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES WERE NOT REALLY FINANCIALLY DUE TO THE RESULT OF GENERAL CONDITIONS IN DISTRICT FIND THE OWNER DUE TO ON THE PROPERTY. SUCH AS, AS A COURTESY TO THE APPLICANT, NINE MEMBERS TODAY. THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION TO THE VARI TO THE SHED. I'D LIKE TO HEAR THAT OPPOSITION BY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR A CONTINUANCE OF THIS CASE WHEN WE HAVE A FULL THAT'S COURTESY AND THAT'S WHAT I CAN YOU CLARIFY. FIVE FOOT VARIANCE, 10 FOOT, TWO FOOT VARIANCE ON THE SIDE. UH, MY LEFT LEFT THE TWO THE SAME AS WHAT'S STATED IN DIALOGUE. I DID CHANGE THE FRONT TO BE FIVE FOOT. ALRIGHT, SAME, SAME. UH, COMMENTS APPLY. GO AHEAD AND TAKE A LOW CALL VOTE SO. OH YES. SO, UM, YEAH, SO, SO, SO WE JUSTICE A LITTLE BIT, UM, AND SIMPLY 'CAUSE AS I LOOK DOWN THE SAME STREET, I DO SEE SEVERAL OTHER CARPORTS THAT ARE KIND OF ALIGNED LIKE THIS. SO, SO IT'S NOT OUT OF, OUT OF, UM, CONSISTENCY WITH, UH, THE OTHERS NEIGHBORHOOD. ALSO, UH, BEING THAT THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION, WHICH IS GENERALLY LOCAL, PRESENT ANY POSITION, DIALOGUE. I'LL ALSO BE VOTING OF MOTION AS COMMISSIONER MAN. I CONCUR WITH THE FINDINGS OF FACT. COMMISSIONER KAPLAN, I CON, I CON FINDS A FACT. COMMISSIONER BURON. I CONCUR. COMMISSIONER DEAN, I CONCUR. COMMISSIONER ZUNIGA. THUMBS UP. SUNGA. COMMISSIONER EZ. COMMISSIONER BRAGMAN. COMMISSIONER ORIAN? [04:30:01] YES, I CAN WITH NINE. IN FAVOR OF YOUR OPPOSITION PASSES AS WELL. PLEASE GET WITH STAFFED. THERE WERE SOME CHANGES THAT THEY'VE MADE TO THE REQUEST. YEAH, I HAVE A PROBLEM. UH, POINT WITHOUT HAVING THE, TO REVIEW, UH, A REVISED DRAFT BECAUSE THE PROBLEMS THAT I SAW IN WHAT WAS CIRCULATED, UH, TO SUFFICIENTLY, UH, SEVERE THAT UH, I'M JUST NOT COMFORTABLE SERVING THEM WITHOUT THE OPPORTUNITY. NOT A PROBLEM. WE CAN PREPARE THEM FOR THE NEXT MEETING. YEAH, DO A DOUBLE AT THE NEXT MEETING. I ALSO, BUT IT WAS THE, EVERYTHING FOUND OUT LATE, BUT I KNOW HER REVISIONS WERE SUBMITTED AND I THINK STAFF DID MAKE, UH, THIS MORNING YES, THIS, THE CHANGES WERE MADE. OKAY. SO, ALRIGHT SIR. AND THAT'S ALL WE HAVE. IT'S 5 44. THE BOARD OF THE THANK YOU COMMISSIONERS. PLEASE GRAB A SANDWICH ON THE WAY OUT. TRIED REAL HARD, . * This transcript was created by voice-to-text technology. The transcript has not been edited for errors or omissions, it is for reference only and is not the official minutes of the meeting.